Games Like Crimson Moon by ProbablyMonsters: Top Action RPGs to Play Next
Crimson Moon is shaping up to be one of those action RPGs that immediately grabs the attention of players who enjoy brutal combat, dark fantasy worlds, flexible builds, and a good old-fashioned fight against things that absolutely should not exist. ProbablyMonsters’ upcoming game puts you in the boots of a Nephilim, a human-angel hybrid battling through the ruined city of Gildenarch, where demons, vampires, corrupted creatures, and fallen supernatural powers have turned every mission into a potential disaster.
What makes Crimson Moon particularly interesting to me is that it does not seem interested in forcing players into the usual RPG boxes. Instead of picking a rigid warrior, mage, or rogue and sticking with that decision forever, the game revolves around equipment, abilities, and build combinations. Add rogue-lite progression, intense third-person melee combat, angelic transformations, and two-player online co-op, and you have a pretty appealing recipe for players who like experimenting with their character rather than simply following a predetermined class.
If you’ve been watching Crimson Moon gameplay and thinking, ‘I need something like this right now,’ there are plenty of games worth checking out. Some nail the gothic atmosphere, others deliver deeper build crafting, and a few are simply fantastic when you want to smash through supernatural enemies with a friend. These are my picks for the best games like Crimson Moon.
How to Fix Crimson Moon Co-Op Connection Failed Error Complete Troubleshooting Guide
1. Devil May Cry 5
If the part of Crimson Moon that excites you most is the sheer spectacle of supernatural melee combat, Devil May Cry 5 is an easy recommendation. Capcom’s action masterpiece is much more focused on stylish execution than RPG progression, but the moment-to-moment combat has the same kind of ridiculous power fantasy that makes playing a supernatural warrior so much fun.
Devil May Cry 5 lets you juggle enemies through the air, switch weapons in the middle of combos, chain abilities together, and turn seemingly impossible encounters into a personal highlight reel. Crimson Moon’s Nephilim powers and angelic abilities immediately bring that same feeling to mind: you’re not supposed to fight like an ordinary human because you’re very much not one.
The major difference is that DMC5 demands much more mechanical precision. There is less emphasis on grinding gear and creating an RPG build, but if you want fast, stylish, brutally satisfying combat, it remains one of the strongest alternatives around.
| What Matches Crimson Moon | Where It Differs |
|---|---|
| Supernatural warriors | Much more skill-focused |
| Stylish melee combat | Limited RPG progression |
| Demons and gothic environments | No co-op campaign |
2. Nioh 2
For me, Nioh 2 is one of the best choices if the build-crafting side of Crimson Moon is what has your attention. Team Ninja took the brutal combat formula associated with Souls-like games and loaded it with an almost absurd amount of equipment, skills, weapon types, and character customization.
The comparison becomes especially interesting because Nioh 2 lets your character transform through Yokai Shift, giving the combat a supernatural second layer. Crimson Moon’s Nephilim transformation and angelic abilities appear to serve a similar purpose: your character is already powerful, but certain abilities let you temporarily push that power into overdrive.
Nioh 2 can be overwhelming at first. The loot system throws an enormous amount of equipment at you, and figuring out what actually matters takes some experimentation. Once everything clicks, though, the game becomes dangerously addictive. One minute you’re testing a new weapon, and three hours later you’re rebuilding your entire character because you found one piece of gear that could make a completely different setup work.
Why play it: incredible combat depth, enormous build variety, challenging bosses, extensive loot, and strong cooperative options.
3. Remnant 2
If the mission-based structure and co-op side of Crimson Moon are what you’re chasing, Remnant 2 deserves a place near the top of the list. It is often described as ‘Dark Souls with guns,’ which is an oversimplification, but it gets the basic appeal across pretty quickly.
You operate from a central hub, select where you want to go, and head into dangerous environments filled with monsters, secrets, randomized encounters, and bosses that can absolutely ruin your evening if you aren’t paying attention. The world changes between playthroughs, which gives the game a fantastic replay value.
What I really like about Remnant 2 is how much freedom you have when building your character. Archetypes, weapons, rings, amulets, traits, and weapon modifications can be combined in ways that create wildly different playstyles. You can build around raw damage, survivability, status effects, critical hits, support abilities, or some wonderfully stupid combination that somehow works.
The co-op is also a major selling point. If Crimson Moon’s two-player missions appeal to you, Remnant 2 is one of the safest recommendations on this list.
4. Darksiders II
Darksiders II might actually be the closest match here when it comes to the combination of mythology, action combat, exploration, and RPG mechanics. You play as Death, one of the legendary Nephilim, while traveling through a world where angels, demons, ancient powers, and corrupted forces constantly collide.
That premise alone makes the comparison with Crimson Moon hard to ignore. The Nephilim concept, celestial mythology, massive supernatural enemies, and apocalyptic environments all hit a similar part of the brain.
Darksiders II also gives you a satisfying loot system. Weapons, armor, secondary equipment, and different stats allow you to shape Death into something that fits your preferred approach. The combat isn’t as technically demanding as Nioh 2 or Devil May Cry 5, but that isn’t necessarily a bad thing. Sometimes I want to pick up a giant weapon, enter a dungeon, and start deleting monsters without having to study a 40-minute build guide.
5. Warhammer: Vermintide 2
Crimson Moon’s co-op concept immediately reminded me of Warhammer: Vermintide 2. Fatshark’s first-person melee action game is built around a simple but incredibly effective idea: get a group together, enter a filthy nightmare of a level, kill hundreds of enemies, survive by the skin of your teeth, and hopefully make it back alive.
The combat is more tactical than it might initially appear. Blocking, dodging, positioning, stamina management, enemy priority, and communication all matter. When a massive horde closes in and special enemies start appearing from every direction, button-mashing usually ends with somebody screaming into voice chat.
The Warhammer setting also gives Vermintide 2 that grim medieval fantasy atmosphere that should feel comfortable to anyone attracted to Crimson Moon’s gothic world. If you want a game where co-op combat is the main event, this is one of the strongest choices available.
6. Warhammer 40,000: Darktide
If you like the Vermintide formula but want something nastier and more industrial, Warhammer 40,000: Darktide takes the same basic philosophy into the brutal world of the 41st millennium.
The setting is obviously very different from Gildenarch, but the gameplay connection is strong. You enter dangerous missions with a squad, fight through waves of hostile creatures, complete objectives, collect rewards, and return to your hub before heading back out for another run.
Darktide also scratches that particular itch of becoming increasingly effective through equipment and character progression. The game is at its best when your squad works as a unit rather than four people independently running around looking for kills.
I’d recommend Darktide particularly to players who are less interested in Crimson Moon’s angelic mythology and more interested in the cooperative monster-slaying loop.
7. Diablo IV
At first glance, Diablo IV might seem like the odd game on this list because of its isometric camera. Mechanically, though, there is plenty here for a Crimson Moon fan to enjoy, especially if the dark fantasy atmosphere and build experimentation are the main attractions.
Diablo IV throws you into a bleak world dominated by an endless conflict between celestial and demonic forces. Its version of dark fantasy is far more focused on gothic horror and religious imagery, but that same feeling of walking through a broken world where supernatural powers have gone completely off the rails is present throughout the campaign.
The biggest attraction is the build system. Skills, equipment, legendary effects, aspects, paragon progression, and other customization layers let you keep refining your character long after the opening hours. If you are the kind of player who enjoys looking at a piece of loot and immediately thinking, ‘Wait, this could completely change my build,’ Diablo IV can consume an alarming amount of free time.
It also works well as a multiplayer experience, making it a natural option for players who want to tackle a dark fantasy world alongside friends.
Which Game Is Most Like Crimson Moon?
There isn’t one perfect replacement because Crimson Moon appears to combine several different ideas rather than copying one specific formula. That’s actually what makes the comparison interesting. Different games on this list capture different pieces of its appeal.
| Game | Best For | Crimson Moon Similarity |
|---|---|---|
| Devil May Cry 5 | Stylish Combat | Supernatural Power Fantasy |
| Nioh 2 | Build Variety | Combat + Customization |
| Remnant 2 | Co-op Missions | Progression + Co-op |
| Darksiders II | Dark Fantasy Adventure | Nephilim + Mythology |
| Vermintide 2 | Co-op Melee | Monster-Slaying Missions |
| Darktide | Squad Combat | Mission-Based Co-op |
| Diablo IV | Loot & Builds | Dark Fantasy + Progression |
My Picks for Different Types of Crimson Moon Players
If I were recommending just one game to each type of player, I’d go with Nioh 2 for build enthusiasts, Remnant 2 for co-op fans, and Darksiders II for anyone hooked on the Nephilim and celestial-versus-demonic mythology. Devil May Cry 5 gets my vote for pure combat spectacle, while Vermintide 2 is the obvious choice when the priority is grabbing friends and turning a monster-infested mission into total chaos.
Diablo IV is the pick for players who can happily spend an evening comparing stats instead of actually playing the game. We’ve all been there. You tell yourself you’ll make one tiny adjustment to your build, and suddenly it’s 2 a.m. and you’re calculating whether a three-percent damage increase is worth replacing a legendary effect.
Final Verdict
Crimson Moon’s appeal comes from the combination of things rather than one isolated feature. It mixes dark fantasy, aggressive melee combat, flexible character builds, supernatural powers, rogue-lite progression, and cooperative missions into a package that should appeal to players who enjoy experimenting with their characters while constantly fighting something horrible.
That’s why there isn’t a single game that completely replaces it. Nioh 2 comes closest to the build-and-combat obsession, Remnant 2 delivers the strongest co-op alternative, and Darksiders II captures much of the same mythological flavor. If what you really want is the feeling of being an absurdly powerful supernatural warrior surrounded by demons and ancient monsters, Devil May Cry 5 is still incredibly hard to beat.
Personally, I’d start with Remnant 2 or Nioh 2. One gives you an excellent excuse to bring a friend along for dangerous missions, while the other can turn character customization into a full-blown hobby. If Crimson Moon ends up scratching that particular dark-fantasy action RPG itch, these seven games should keep your backlog busy for a very long time.
